Viral Escape from a Candidate HIV-1 Vaccine Targeting Protease Cleavage Sites Is Associated with a Dramatic Fitness Loss in SIVmac239-Infected Cynomolgus Macaques.

Abstract

A novel HIV-1 vaccine candidate under development targeting the highly conserved protease cleavage regions reduced viral acquisition and delayed disease progression in a macaque SIV-challenge model. Breakthrough virus isolated from vaccinees and control animals were sequenced in the regions surrounding the SIV protease cleavages. We identified unique viral mutations that were associated with alterations in viral load and maintenance of CD4+ T cell counts in vaccinees. To evaluate whether the vaccine-elicited mutations were detrimental to virus fitness, we produced 11 mutant constructs and transfection-derived viral stocks harboring mutations in both PCS2 (in CA/p2) and PCS12 (in Nef) that had emerged at high frequency during breakthrough viremia. Virus preparations harboring mutations displayed impaired proteolytic Gag processing, reduced viral RNA incorporation and p27-CA content. These mutants were also compromised in their ability to replicate in primary cells and cell lines. Interestingly, we observed only partial compensation of these PCS2 defects by downstream mutation at PCS12. In sum, we demonstrate that vaccine-elicited immunity directed to viral protease cleavage regions impair viral escape, and breakthrough virus cannot easily restore replicative fitness.